Skip to main content

Jakarta EE Platform Project

Home for the Jakarta EE Platform Team

Jakarta EE Platform Call

Date: 2022-04-12

Present:

  • Ivar Grimstad (Eclipse Foundation)
  • Jim Krueger (IBM)
  • Jared Anderson (IBM)
  • Emily Jiang (IBM)
  • Thomas Watson (IBM)
  • Scott Stark (Red Hat)
  • Arjan Tijms (OmniFaces / Piranha)
  • John Clingan (Red Hata)
  • Cesar Hernández (Tomitribe)
  • BJ Hargrave (IBM)
  • Petr Aubrecht (Payara)
  • Scott Marlow (Red Hat)
  • Lukas Jungmann (Oracle)
  • Majid Mostafavi
  • James Perkins (Red Hat)
  • Ryan Cuprak (Jakarta EE Ambassadors)
  • Ed Bratt (Oracle)
  • Dmitry Kornilov (Oracle)
  • Kenji Kazumura (Fujitsu)

Agenda and Minutes

Jakarta EE 10 Status (standing agenda item)

  • Core Profile TCK underway (Scott Stark)
  • TCKs in general progressing slowly
  • Notice sent to spec leads reminding them of the May 1 deadline for getting to the final ballot and asking them to contact spec committee mentor or platform team.
    • Nothing reported yet
  • About half way through. 10 that hasn’t started ballot yet
  • Deadline is May 1st
  • Faces+Security: mostly about finalizing the TCK work
  • Can we drop off the specs that can not make May 1st?
    • Some specs might be ok: such as Messaging
    • EL probably not because of the dependencies
    • Some specs might be ready but the spec cmt have not done the ballot
  • Platform TCK Standalone TCK results with GlassFish 7.0 (not always the ballot ci)
  • Scott will ask the spec committee to get the status of ballot progress of the 10 remaining specs:
    Websocket, server pages
    • Scott M said websocket tcks passed with glassfish
  • Glassfish status:
    • Ajan said there are some failures but he is working on the fixes
    • Concurrency is missing from the list. Glassfish needs to pass Concurrency tck (to be done)
  • Scott S will send out a note with all open issues for TCKs that prevent specs from entering the ballot.
    • Action: help out with the open issues. Some of them might be getting an impl passing the tcks.
  • security : new security tests arquillian based (such as openid connect); also look for implementations to pass the tcks
  • Platform spec, core profile also need to go to ballot
  • Scott will look at the open issues next week
  • to see how they are impacting the spec progress. \

Current Ballot status

  • Core Profile
    • Annotation 2.1 Ballot complete February 9
    • CDI Lite 4.0 Included in CDI 4.0 or a separate ballot?
    • Expression Language 5.0
    • Interceptors 2.1 Ballot complete April 6
    • JSON Binding 3.0 Ballot complete March 18
    • JSON Processing 2.1 Ballot complete March 24
    • RESTful Web Services 3.1 Ballot complete April 6 \
  • Web Profile
    • Authentication 3.0
    • CDI 4.0 Ballot started March 30, completes April 13
    • Concurrency 3.0
    • Faces 4.0
    • JSTL 3.0
    • Pages 3.1
    • Persistence 3.1 Ballot complete April 6
    • Security 3.0
    • Servlet 6.0
    • WebSocket 2.1 \
  • Full Platform
    • Activation 2.1 Ballot complete January 26
    • Authorization 2.1
    • Batch 2.1
    • Connectors 2.1
    • Mail 2.1 Ballot complete February 11
    • Messaging 3.1
    • SOAP with Attachments 3.0 Ballot complete March 15
    • XML Bindings 4.0 Ballot complete April 7
    • XML Web Services 4.0 Ballot complete April 6 \

[Emily] Discuss to retain the TCKs for JSON-B and JSON-P at platform TCKs

  • This was previously discussed in the Mar 15 meeting as well as a platform TCK meeting.
  • What is the impact for EE 10?
    • As long as no changes are done to the component spec TCKs, these ballots are not affected
    • Changes to the platform TCK is only affected by the ballot for the Platform (and profiles)
  • Concern about consistency between the component specification tests and the platform tests
  • Some specs: JSON-B, JSON-P TCKs
  • Arjan would like to see EL tcks running in EE container \

Back to the top